Nice Work, but too many effects sometimes, but they are nice. The kills aren't special i think, maybe because i only play Halo when i am with my friend, @ his home. The Music is ok, but this is the right soundtrack for the video !

i am not a big fan of the halo games, but its nice to see a halo vid here, its really entertaining! THX nice work

Fast paced, a little too fast at times making the frags difficult to see. Never the less editing was slick and defined, the syncing was done well, but I believe a better song could of exploited the frags a little more. Rare to see a Halo video on the vault, but, im pleasantly surprised. Great video, nice work!

WTF IZ DIS GAYMELOLOLPQRS
Jk.
Excellent movie in my opinion, nice and fast paced. The way I like it.
Some of the colors were a little bit too dark, but the song choice was a nice one. The frags were okay although could have been a little bit better.

Well let me first start off with "less is more" because in this case, its like a raccoon putting on eyeliner and mascara...

The Gameplay was great i thought ad the music was well syncopated with the editing and gameplay, which is always good. But I would take my rating with a grain of salt, because i know of a lot of other people who would rate this a 10/10, because overall it was a very good watch.

Although the style was very hit or miss, its not to say it was a horrible video and enjoyably, i couldn't keep my eyes off the screen, which is what every good editor wants ;]

7.8/10

Good work , good to see halo 3 section in TMV

The title for the video fits perfctly with the editing. I think the idea the editor was going for was great but I think he over edited a bit to much. The music choice was great, I mean who doesn't like metallica? For the most part, the clips were great yet there were a few "filler" clips. The quality was great and the angles were perfet for video

I really liked the intro countdown, and the syncíng in the first 20 seconds.
2.15 was something I would never figure out to get fitted into that part.

Frags are very good, though could some of them be left out, like the plasma at 1.30. other than that; very good gameplay.

Editing was good and bad, I really disliked that there were too many effects at some points, wich took away alot.
Too many angle views too, a few of them were not necessary, though can't i say that the angles were bad, infact i think all of them were perfect, just too much. Effects were well synced, just too much at the same time.

Music wise do I think you chose one of the worse songs from Metallica.

Quality was clear and sharp.

Overall score: 7.4

atiemark is a badass austrian so i have to give him an 8.2

I couldn't really get into this one, the effects really got in the way of the game play, and the music was not my cup of tea, to say the least. I did appreciate the 3D work in the intro. I can see this video strongly appealing to a very particular audience. Unfortunately, I'm not one of them.

A very entertaining watch for sure but not my favorite from Atiemark. Atiemark is a good friend of mine and I have always been a fan of him and watching before-hand I didn't think that I would like this video at all. (due to the music) Well, I was wrong. He made a very enjoyable montage with a small amount of clips and a great insight on what has been going on with the halo 3 community. I don't feel like going over every pro and con so I will just leave my rating somewhere below ;D
8.4/10

Nice work Atie, you know your programs very well. Loved the fast-pace style, kept me on my feet.

This is definitely a very good frag video. The editing fit the music and the frags very well, and the music was just downright amazing. You gotta love Metallica.

9.2/10.0

wow! That was... Frantic! All over the place and i'd have to pray or have a stupidly lucky day to have the skill like that! DO you thiknk you can give me some tips? :P

Too face paced and too much edited crap on the screen to tell what's going on. Trying to center the entire video around a single subject, song, or style can be good, but it has to be a good center. Being frantic can be good, but frantic doesn't mean keeping you from seeing what is going on.

I really like this Movie! The editing is nice and the music fits perfectly
wich causes a special athmosphere.